John Whelan wrote on Tue, Jan 26, 2016 01:53 AM UTC:
Re: "you can't please everyone" - No, but it is not as though I ever demanded you do 1 Amazon & 2 queens. It was 1 of several alternative suggestions. And these were merely examples to suggest that the issue is not insoluble.
Re: "close to standard chess in spirit". Seems to me the pieces of FIDE chess have a high degree of ability to threaten each other without being threatened back. Even the Queen, the most powerful piece on the board, can be threatened by the 2 knights. Seems to me a lot of that is lacking here, for all the variety of pieces. If an opposing piece cannot threaten you back, it is probably less powerful.