[ List Earliest Comments Only For Pages | Games | Rated Pages | Rated Games | Subjects of Discussion ]
Comments by Larry Wheeler
Jeremy updated the colors today, using codes I sent him.
Jeremy, from reading the rules I would say the unprotected pawns were an oversight (he claims that all pawns are protected). The problem with this is that it limits Black's replies, so that the moves played to counter the attacks on the unprotected pawns limit the variety of openings available.
BoardGameGeek.com has some useful info, some brought over from the Navia Dratp Enthusiasts Yahoo group, like an easy-to-read copy of the rules with FAQ. I don't suppose there's any reason to repeat those here, unless someone has an improved version. There are many obscure combinations of the rules which we now know will never be officially ruled on, many of which will never happen (but could), like my favorite: a ring of three Kanabas confining each other! I think the game has to be respected in its entirety as an artistic concept, even though the names and forms of the playing elements may seem arbitrary to some. Most of the 'ugliness' of the pieces owes to the fact that most of them come unpainted. See the game Dreamblade for how to do it right (but it's still a collectible game, unfortunately).
The rules as stated here don't make it clear that you can't use part of your last ring to capture your opponent's last ring, or moreover break your last ring at all. The Archimedeans' (http://www.archim.org.uk/eureka/53/gess.htmlrules) are much more precise: [begin quote] The object of the game is to capture (or disable) your opponent’s ring or rings; if at the end of a move either player has no ring then he loses: the player who has just moved being considered first, so you cannot use part of your ring to take your opponent’s ring or rings. It is possible to have more than one ring at a time—indeed this may be considered desirable—and you may destroy one or more of your own rings provided that you still have at least one at the end of your move. [end quote] This distinction is important in a game I have going on now!
That was mentioned farther down in the comments, on 2004-9-22, I think.
5 comments displayed
Permalink to the exact comments currently displayed.